- , BO GIAO DUC VA DAO TAO ' ' TRUoNG DAI • HOC • KINH TE TP. HCM NGUYEN VAN TUYEN MOl QUAN H:f: GIUA KIEU HOI, PilAT TRIEN TAl CHINH vA TANG TRUONG Chuyen nganh: Tai chinh- Ngan hang Ma s6: 60340201 LUAN • VAN THAC • Si KINH TE NGUdi HUONG DAN KHOA HQC: GIAO SV TRAN NGQC THO TP. H6 Chi Minh -Nam 2013 rf.J TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.com LOICAMDOAN Toi xin cam doan r~ng lu~n van "M6i quan h~ gifra kiSu h6i, phat triSn tai chinh Va tang truemg" la cong trinh nghien Cllu CUa rieng toi. Dfr li~u duqc sir d\}ng trong lu~n van la trung thlJC duqc thu th~p tir nhfrng ngu6n dang tin c~y va cac kSt qua trinh bay trong Iu~n van chua duqc cong b6 ~i b&t kY cong trinh nghien CUu nao tru6c day.
NSu phat hi~n c6 b&t Icy gian l~n nao, toi xin chju toan b9 trach nhi~m tru6c H()i d6ng.HCM, thang 10 nam 2013 Tac gia luin van l t TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.com MUCLUC • • Trang ph\1 bia LOi cam doan Danh ml,lc Cl,lm tir viSt t~t Danh m\lc cac bang, bi€u Danh ml,lC cac hinh ve, d6 thi Tom t~t. T6ng quan cac kSt qua nghien CUu tru&c day. Phuong phap nghien c(ru .2 Phuong phap nghien c(ru. Nc)i dung va cac kSt qua nghien c(ru.
Trang 54 Tai li~u tham khao TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.com DANH MUC • CUM • TUVIET TAT Cl}m vi~t tit Ten ttiy dti ti~ng Anh Ten diy dti ti~ng Vi~t Autoregressive Distributed Phuong phap phan phoi tr~ tv' ' ARDL Lag h6iquy Balance of Payment Statistics Nien giam thong ke can can BOPSY Yearbook thanh tmin CPI Consumer Price Index Chi so gia tieu dung FDI Foreign Direct Investment BAu tu tzvc ti€p nu6c ngoai FEM Fixed Effects Model Mo hinh hi~u (rng cb dinh GDP Gross Domestic Product Tfing san phfrm quoc n()i Generalized Method of Phuong phap u6c luQ'Ilg GMM Moments GMM IMF International Monetary Fund Quy tien t~ quoc te Official Development ODA H6 trq phat tri€n chinh thuc Assistance Phuong phap binh phuong OLS Ordinary Least Squares J nho nhAt Phuong phap binh phuong PFMOLS Panel Fully Modified nho nhftt v6i dfr li~u bang Ordinary Least Squares duqc hi~u chinh hofm toan REM Random Effects Model Mo hinh hi~u (rng ng~u nhien System Generalized Method of Phuong phap u6c luQllg SGMM Moments SGMM TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.com ~l}m vi~t tit Ten diy dii ti~ng Anh Ten diy dii ti~ng Vi~t United Nations Conference on Di~n dan thuong m~i va phat UNCTAD Trade and Development tri~n cua Lien Hi~p Qu6c I Mo hinh vector hi~u chinh sai VECM Var Error Correction Model ' so WB World Bank Ngan hang the giai WDI World Development Indicators Cac chi so phat trien the gi6i i. 1 TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.com DANH MVC cAc BANG, BIEU Bang 1.1: Nhfrng u6e lm;mg va dv dmin eho dong ehay kiSu h6i vao eae qu6e gia dang phat triSn Bang 2.1: Bang tom luge eae nghien diu diSn hinh tru6e day vS dS tai kiSu h6i Bang 3.1: Bang tom luge vS eae biSn nghien e(ru Bang 3.2: Bang th6ng ke tom t~t eae biSn hBi quy ehinh Bang 4.1: KSt qua mo hinh hBi quy tae d()ng eua kiSu h6i va tang truOn.2: HBi quy v&i Deposits la biSn d~i di~n eho phat triSn tai ehinh Bang 4.3: HBi quy v6i Loans la biSn d~i di~n eho phat triSn tai ehinh Bang 4.4: HBi quy v6i Credit la biSn d~i di~n eho phat triSn tai ehinh Bang 4.5: HBi quy v6i M2 la biSn d~i di~n eho phat triSn tai ehinh TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.com DANH MVC cAc HiNH vE, DO THJ ffinh 1.1: Top 10 qu6c gia dang phat triSn c6 ngu6n kiSu h6i 16n nhftt ffinh 1.2: Top 10 qu6c gia c6 cy I~ kiSu h6i trong GDP 16n nhftt ffinh 1.3: KiSu h6i va cac ngu6n v6n khac chay vao cac nu6c dang phat trien TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.com 1 Tom tit (Abstract) KiSu hBi dong vai tro ngay cang quan tr<;mg trong t6ng sB cac dong vBn qu6c ts nhung m6i quan h~ giua kisu hBi va tang tru6ng v~n chua dugc nghien Clru m<?t each dfiy du va chi tiSt. Do do, bai nghien Clru nay se di sau tim hi~u vS m<?t trong nhfrng mBi lien h~ gifra kiSu hBi va tang tru6ng, d~c bi~t la nghien ctru vS phat tri~n cua linh V\fC tai chinh dja phuang anh hu6ng dSn kha nang t~n d\lng kiSu hBi cua m<?t quBc gia nhu thS nao. Noi each khac ffi\lC dich cua bai nghien ctru la tim hi~u xem phat tri~n tai chinh anh hu6ng dSn sv tac d()ng cua kiSu hBi dSn tang tru6ng nhu thS nao.
Lu~ van sir d\lng dfr li~u m&i dugc c~p nh~t cua 40 qu6c gia dang phat tri~n co thu nh~p th~p va trung binh, kSt qua cho th~y r~ng kiSu hBi thuc dAy tang tru6ng o nhiing quBc gia co h~ thBng tai chinh kern phat tri~n thong qua vi~c cung c~p m<?t each thuc dfiu tu tai chinh khac va giup quBc gia do vugt qua nhfrng kho khan thanh khoan. Cac quBc gia dang phat tri~n thuemg g~p kho khan trong vi~c vay vBn, do do kiSu hBi co th~ gop phfin b6 sung cho S\1' thiSu phat tri~n tai chinh va thuc dAy tang tru6ng. MBi quan h~ nay ki~m soat tinh n<?i sinh cua kiSu hBi va phat tri~n tai chinh b~ng each sir d1;1ng mo hinh SGMM (System Generalized Method of Moments), va mBi quan h~ nay cling khong ph\1 thu()c vao bi~n phap phat tri~n tai chinh C\1 th~ dugc sir d1;1ng. Nghien f ctru ciing dua ra nhfrng d~n chilng chilng minh r~ng kiSu hBi la m<?t kenh dfiu tu rna co th~ thuc dAy tang tru6ng, d~c bi~t la khi rna llnh V\fC tai chinh v~n chua th~ dap ilng duqc nhu cfiu cua nguai dan.
Tir khoa: KiSu hBi, phat tri~n tai chinh va tang tru6ng. TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail. Theo u6c tinh cua Ngan hang ThS gi6i, kiSu h6i d~t 479 tY USD trong nam 2011, trong d6 381 tY USD duqc chuy@n sang cac nu6c dang phat tri@n, tuong {rng v6i khoang 215 tri~u lao d<)ng di cu tren toan thS gi6i. Nam 2012, luqng kiSu hfii chinh thuc d6 vao cac nu6c dang phat tri@n u6c tinh d~t 406 cy USD, tang khoang 6.
Dong kiSu h6i nay kY VQng se tang 8% trong nam 2013, 10% trong nam 2014 va d~t 534 cy do trong nam 20 15 (theo Migration and Development Brief 19 - The World Bank 20/1112012). Cac nu6c dang phat tri@n hi~n d{rng d~u vS ngu6n kiSu h6i chay vao, gBm nhiing qu6c gia nhu: An DQ, Trung Qu6c, Philippines, Mexico, Nigeria,. theo s6 li~u th6ng ke u6c tinh trong nam 20 12 cua World Bank. f TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.
- ------------ 3 {US$ billion~ 2012e) 70 66 • 24 21 18 14 14 9 7 Hinh 1.1 Top 10 qu6c gia dang phat triSn c6 nguBn kiSu h6i 16n nhit (Ngu6n: Migration and Development Brief 19- The World Bank 20111/2012) • D6i v&i mc;>t s6 nu&c tiSp nh~, kiSu h6i c6 thS chiSm dSn m9t ph~n ba GDP cua hQ. Cac nu&c d(rng d~u vS ti I~ kiSu h6i trong GDP bao g6m cac nSn kinh tS nho nhu Tajikistan (47%), Liberia (31 %), Kyrgyz Republic (29%), va Lesotho (27%) theo s6 li~u thdng ke vao nam 2011. 0 nhiing qudc gia khac, I thong thuoog kiSu h6i chiSm khoang hon 10% GDP. , I I I I I I I I I I TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.com 4 {%of GDP, 2011) • 47 31 29 27 23 22 21 21 18 18 Hinh 1.2 Top 10 qu6c gia co t)r 1~ kiSu hBi trong GDP l&n nhfit (Ngu6n: Migration and Development Brief 19- The World Bank 20/11/2012) VS m~t ly thuySt, kiSu hBi giup tang v6n tich lily trong nu6c, tir do gop ph~n thuc d~y tang tru6ng kinh tS thong qua m9t s6 kenh nhu: ~ Trvc tiSp tac d9ng dSn ngu6n v6n tich lily trong nu6c ~ Giam chi phi v6n vi cung quy cho vay tang len tu ngu6n kiSu hBi ~ Gop ph~n fm djnh vi mo trong nu6c do kiSu hBi dugc sir d\lllg nhu m9t ph~n cua v6n d~u tu trong nu6c, giam thiSu hfit 6n kinh tS do thiSu h\lt v6n d~u tu.
TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.com 5 M~c du cim quan trQng ngay cang gia tang cua kiSu h6i trong tfmg cac dong v6n qu6c ts nhung m6i quan h~ giua kiSu h6i va tang truemg kinh ts vfin chua dugc nghien cl:ru thvc nghi~m m()t each ro rang va d~y du. Trong khi d6 thi m6i quan h~ giiia tang truemg va cac ngudn v6n nu6c ngoai khac chimg h1;1n nhu d~u tu tflJC tiSp nu6c ngoai (FDI) hay cac dong tiSn h6 trg chinh thuc (Official Flows) thi l1;1i dugc nghien cl:ru vo cung sau r()ng. Hon niia, kiSu h6i ciing dugc sir d1,mg chu ySu cho tieu dung, nen ciing it nhiSu c6 tac d()ng dSn tang truemg trong dai h1;1n. US$ billion 600 Remittances 500 400 300 200 100 o~Nm~~~~~mO~Nm~~~~~mo~~-- mmmmmmmmmmoooooooooo~~Nm~IJ) mmmmmmmmmmoooooooooooo~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~.-<NNNNNNNNNNNNOOOO N N N N Sources: World Develooment Indicators and World Bank DECPG estimates • Hinh 1.3 KiSu h6i va cac ngu6n v6n khac chay vao cac nu6c dang phat tri@n (Ngudn: Migration and Development Brief 19- The World Bank 20111/2012) KiSu h6i la m()t trong nhiing ngu6n thu ngo1;1i t~ 6n dinh trong nhiing nam qua, b&t ch&p tinh hinh tai chinh, kinh tS thS gi6i.
Ludng v6n d~u tu thuemg c6 xu huang chay vao nSn kinh tS dang c6 d&u hi~u khai sAc va chay ra khi nSn TIEU LUAN MOI download : skknchat@gmail.com 6 kinh t~ suy thmii nhung dong kiSu h6i thi se khong c6 nhiSu bi~n d()ng nhu nhiing dong v6n khac. Dva vao hinh ve 1.3 a tren ta c6 thS th~y r~ng kiSu h6i trong giai do~n 1998- 2001lien 1\lc tang khi rna luBng vBn d~u tutu nhan thao lui do anh huang cua CUQC khung hoang tai chinh tiSn t~ Chau A. Xu huang nay ti~p 1\IC tang ngay ca khi cac dong v6n duqc xem la kha 6n djnh khac nhu FDI va ODA giam trong giai do~n 2000 - 2003, va kiSu h6i cung chi giam r~t nhy a giai ao~n 2006 - 2009 trong khi hai dong v6n con l~i c6 Sl,l Sl,lt giam r~t dang kS bm tac d()ng cua cu()c khung hoang kinh t~ th~ gi6i. Do v~y, kiSu h6i duqc ngm1i nh~ sir dl,lng cho chi tieu cling se mang tinh it bi~n d()ng hon so v6i nhiing khoan lqi nhu~n thu duqc tir d~u tu.
D6i v6i nhiing qu6c gia c6 thu nh~p th~p thi diSu nay l~i cang c6 y nghia vi nhiSu gia dinh sinh s6ng dva vao nguBn ki@u h6i giri v@ tir nu6c ngoai, cu()c s6ng cua hQ v6i muc s6ng c6 thS n6i la ngheo kh6 va chi du trang trai cho nhiing nhu c~u thi~t y~u. Kinh t~ kh6 khan a nhiing nu6c nay cang Ia d()ng lvc m~nh me cho nguai dan xu~t khfru lao d()ng va chuySn ti@n v@ qu6c gia nuoi s6ng gia dinh. Ngay ca khi ki@u hBi mang y nghia la chuy@n ti@n danh nghia d@ che d~y cho khoan d~u tu, ki@u h6i cling it chju bi~n d()ng th~t thuang cua dong d~u tu gian ti~p vao thi truang m6i n6i.