Seton Hall University eRepository @ Seton Hall Theses Spring 5-2012 To Infinity and Beyond: A Critique of the Aesthetic White Cube Whitney B. Birkett Seton Hall University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.edu/theses Recommended Citation Birkett, Whitney B., "To Infinity and Beyond: A Critique of the Aesthetic White Cube" (2012).edu/theses/209 1 J To INFINITY AND BEYOND: A CRITIQUE OF THE AESTHETIC WHITE CUBE Whitney Fehl Birkett Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Museum Professions Seton Hall University May 2012 Juergen Heinrichs, Ph. Faculty Advisor ABSTRACT From princely collections to public museums, the history of the display of art has been rich and varied. In the 1930s, New York's Museum of Modern Art and its director Alfred H.
developed the aesthetic "white cube," a display method that was revolutionary in its objective focus and clean execution and fulfilled the unique needs of its era. Since this time, our society and culture have changed, yet art museum display has largely remained in stasis. Although European movements and institutions are mentioned, this thesis explores the history of museum display and the development of the white cube through the lens of the American art museum and seeks to offer practical alternatives. The time has come to embrace new contextual and interactive techniques that better suit the needs of our era and encourage viewer engagement and understanding rather than passive consumption.
1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter Page I. HISTORY OF MUSEUM DISPLAY AND PRECURSORS TO THE WHITE CUBE 7 III., THE MUSEUM OF MODERN ART, AND THE 20 DEVELOPMENT OF THE WHITE CUBE N. LIMITATIONS OF THE WHITE CUBE 35 V. EXPERIMENTATION AND ALTERNATIVES TO THE WHITE CUBE 44 VI.
BEST PRACTICES 58 VII. INTRODUCTION At 5 :00 in the evening on October 20, 20 II, a few dozen protesters gathered outside of New York's Museum of Modem Art. Restricted to a small patch of sidewalk just outside the museum's main entrance, the group drew the attention of museum visitors, passersby, and even art critic Jerry Saltz, who joined the group in chanting, "speaking is a force!"l The protesters, known as "Occupy Museums," were there as an offshoot of the Occupy Wall Street movement in opposition to what they feel are "temples of cultural elitism controlled by the 1%." In their manifesto, written by Brooklyn-based artist and organizer Noah Fischer, they lament the commercialization of art and the transformation of museums into cultural "rating agencies" that alienate the interests of the lower classes. 2 Since their first protest, Occupy Museums has become a weekly event in New York City, and its participants have picketed the New Museum, the American Museum of Natural History, and have joined the Teamsters Local 814 to protest Sotheby's lockout of its art handlers.
3 The reasoning behind the protests has been justly questioned. Do museums really deserve the blame for advancing the interests of the rich, for an inflated art market, or for elevating one artist over another? I would say no. While the profile and approach of museums vary greatly, no museum is perfect. In recent years, there has been a wave of blockbuster exhibitions funded largely by corporate money and wealthy donors.
These shows often focus I Michael H. Miller, "'Occupy Museums' Protests In Front of MoM A With Jerry Saltz," Gallerist NY, accessed March 20, 2012, http://www.coml20111l0/occupy-museums-protests-in-front-of-moma-with jerry-saltz. 2 Noah Fischer, "Occupy Museums! Speaking Out in Front of the Cannons," Paddy Johnson, accessed March 20, 20 12, http://paddyjohnson.comipostIl1652516894/occupy-museums-speaking-out-in-front-of-the cannons. 3 "Occupy Museums," Facebook, accessed March 20,2012, https:llwww.comipages/Occupy Museums/148 157235282782.
more on entertainment and spectacle than the enlightenment of their visitors. But in today's capitalist economy, with government contributions on the decline, museums depend on private contributions to remain open and accessible to their communities. Museums often significantly underpay their staff. Arguing against the equation or art with capital and "spectacularly out of touch auctions,'.4 it would seem that the protesters' true target should be commercial galleries and auction houses.
While a museum exhibition may inadvertently increase the market value of a work of art displayed, codes of ethics seek to ensure that no museum constituent benefits financially from such an increase. Donors are discouraged from selling works for a period of time following an exhibition, staff members are banned from any perceived conflicts of interest, and museums only deaccession works after intense consideration and scrutiny. Additionally, the charge that museums elevate "one individual genius over another human being"S seems frivolous. Artists' desires are not a museums' primary concern.
I would argue that selectivity not only ensures a valuable experience, but also keeps our cultural institutions functioning. Most museum are committed to presenting works they deem to be appropriate to their mission and of the highest quality. Furthermore, if museums were indiscriminate in their collecting, storage room space and financial resources would quickly run out. However, the Occupy Museum protests are a symptom of a larger problem currently facing our cultural institutions.
Right or wrong, museums have a reputation for being elitist institutions skewed toward the needs of the wealthy and highly educated. A report published in 1991 by the J. Paul Getty Book Distribution Center found that non-visitors to eleven American museums thought of them as stuffy and even intimidating. Although this report is now 20 years old and many of the participating institutions have long ago enacted reform, the basic principles 4 Fischer.
2 still hold for many contemporary museums. While many museum professionals hope that their institutions will act as inspiration for further learning, they may in fact discourage potential visitors. "I'm embarrassed," one participant stated of the National Gallery in Washington DC, "my overall feeling is. people are there because they know what they are looking at, and I don't.',6 Even after visiting the Denver Art Museum, another visitor felt unwelcomed because of the museum's use oftenns that "if you were really into history or really into art you would probably recognize, but I didn't knoW.,,7 Museum professionals should not dismiss the findings of the Getty report and the issues th raised by Occupy protesters.
Beginning in the 19 century, museums have defined themselves as public service institutions dedicated to the advancement of knowledge in the communities they serve. Additionally, most museums in the United States are nonprofit institutions and seek additional support from both the United States government and private individuals. If a museum does not appear to serve all individuals, regardless of economic status or experience level, it may lose the support of such patrons specifically as well as the public in general. Therefore, it is important that the operation of museums remain transparent and accountable to their communities.
They must provide intellectually engaging experiences that are accessible to all members of the community, yet move beyond mere entertainment. In accordance with their missions, museums such as the National Gallery of Art in Washington DC must spread knowledge to "the widest possible student and general public,,,g while those like MoMA encourage "an ever-deeper understanding and enjoyment of modem and contemporary art.,,9 6 Insights: Museums, Visitors, Attitudes, Expectations: A Focus Group Experiment (Los Angeles: J. Paul Getty Trust, 1991), 10. 8 "Mission Statement," National Gallery ofArt, accessed March 20,2012, http://www.gov/xio/mission.
9 "About MoMA," The Museum ofModem Art, Accessed March 20,2012, http://www. 3 Furthennore, today's museums cannot afford to alienate any members of the public they claim to serve. Lowry, director of the Museum of Modern Art, warned of a coming economic stonn as New York's Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg asked the Department of Cultural Affairs to decrease spending by 7% as of July of 20 10.
10 Three years later, an online survey of 383 institutional members of the American Association of Museums continues to confinn Lowry's fear. In 2010, over 70% of museums in the United States reported experiencing moderate to very severe economic stress, and approximately 53% reported a decrease in overall revenue. The economic conditions were even worse among museums in my own mid-Atlantic region, with 82% reporting some degree of stress. The situation begins to seem more dire when we consider what the new AAM report describes as a "perhaps pennanent" philanthropic shift away from cultural organizations toward "social services, environment, and other causes.,,11 The continued financial hardships have forced museums across the country to take action.
As its endowment decreased by 25% during the 2009 fiscal year, the Metropolitan Museum of Art announced a hiring freeze and the closure of 15 satellite stores around the country.12 By 2010, nearly 35% of museums had similar freezes in place and were relying more and more on unpaid volunteers. Other museums resorted to reductions in staff benefits as well as layoffs and furloughs.13 Although only a relatively small number of museums have resorted to increased admission prices, more and more instances are making their way into the news. Earlier this year, 10 Carol Vogel, "Museums Fear Lean Days Ahead," The New York Times, (2008), http://www.coml2008/ I 0/20/artsldesignl20muse.html?pagewanted=all (accessed March 20, 2012). Museums Continue to Serve Despite Stress: A Report from the American Association of Museums (April20 11 )," American Association of Museums, accessed March 20, 2012, us.org!uploadlACME II-report FINAL.
12 Carol Vogel, "Met Museum to Close Shops, Freeze Hiring," The New York Times, (2009), http://artsbeat.coml2009/02/23/met-museum-to-c1ose-shops-freeze-hiring! (accessed March 20, 2012). Museums Continue to Serve Despite Stress," 2-7. 4 the Museum of Modem Art raised its adult admission price from $20 to $25,14 and just this month The J. Paul Getty Museum eliminated its free evening parking in order to maintain financial stability.
IS At the same time, lower than average attendance has been an issue for all but the most resilient institutions. According to a National Endowment for the Arts survey of 1800 adults living in the United States, fewer adults visited cultural organizations than any time previously recorded. Visitation to art museums and galleries in particular dropped by about 3 million between 2002 and 2008. Even among women and the most educated, two key demographics, the number of visits notably declined.
16 Since this time, many museums have reported increased attendance due to a decrease in public travel and a commitment to lower cost "staycations." While people once traveled broadly for vacations, many are now choosing to stay closer to home, visiting nearby attractions. However, caused by the decrease in tourism, combined with budget reductions and a decline in school group visitations, 30% of museums were still 17 experiencing declining attendance in 2010. It stands to reason that as the needs of museums and their audiences change, so must the museums themselves. This is not only true for management and education, but also the very ways in which museum professionals think about and display the artifacts in their care.
After all, display is the main way museums communicate with visitors. Yet, while technology and 14 Carol Vogel, "Museum of Modem Art Raising Admission and Membership Fees," The New York Times, (20 II), http://artsbeat.coml2011107128/museum-of-modem-art-raising-admission-and membership-fees/# (accessed March 20,2012). 15 Mike Boehm, "Getty Ends Free Evening Parking, Sets $10 Fee after 5 P.,"Los Angeles Times, (2011), http://latimesblogs.comlculturemonster/20l1l11lgetty-museum-parking-increase-. 16 "National Endowment for the Arts 2008 Survey of Public Participation in the Arts," National Endowment for the Arts, accessed March 20,2012, http://www.gov/researchl2008-SPPA.
Museums Continue to Serve Despite Stress," 1. 5 governance have evolved, the method of display in American art museums has remained largely intact for nearly a century. This thesis seeks to bring to light and provide alternatives to what Brian O'Doherty termed the "social, financial, and intellectual snobbery',ls of the aesthetic "white cube" display primarily developed by Alfred H. and the Museum of Modern Art.
Although the primary focus is on art museums in the United States, I will be mentioning a select number of European institutions and developments beginning with the history of display from princely collections to the development of public museums. I will focus on two precursors that th significantly influenced the ideas and development of the white cube.